Exploring the Best Afternoon Tea Spots in New York City

Join me on an afternoon tea journey as we explore the delightful offerings at the Palm Court and Afternoon Tea at Tiffany’s Blue Box Cafe!

Afternoon Tea at Tiffany’s Blue Box Cafe"

Scones with Clotted Cream and Jam: 

The scones at Tiffany’s were warm and soft, with a fluffy interior. They weren’t freshly baked, but still pleasant and not dry. The exterior was smooth, and they pulled apart easily. They had a buttery aroma and were the kind of scones you savor slowly, feeling a bit fancy.

The jam and cream elevated the scones. I applied the cream first, then the jam, which made each bite soft and balanced. The jam was sweet and fruity, enhancing the overall experience. Together, they made the scones feel both cozy and elegant. Rating - 8/10: Delicious but not extraordinary.

Sandwiches:

The sandwiches were adorably small and perfect for a fancy setting. Most were fresh and flavorful, with subtle and balanced tastes. The fillings were smooth, and the bread was thin and soft, making the sandwiches feel light and special.

Some sandwiches were perfect, with soft bread and well-proportioned fillings. Others were a bit plain or dry, lacking a little something, which made the standout ones even more impressive. Rating: 9.5/10: Some were extremely delicious, but a few were bland or dry.

Desserts: 

The desserts were stunning, like something out of a movie. They were beautifully crafted and fresh, with soft, well-baked cakes. Some desserts were perfectly balanced in sweetness, while others were too sweet or a bit plain, making the exceptional ones shine. Rating: 9/10: Scrumptious, but some were overly sweet or not to my taste.

Service: The service was excellent, with friendly and attentive staff who detailed every dish. However, they were busy, which slowed down the service slightly, and a couple of dishes weren’t as fresh. Still, everything was delicious. Rating - 9/10

Afternoon Tea at Palm Court, Plaza Hotel

Scones with Clotted Cream and Jam: 

The scones at Palm Court were warm and soft, with a smooth top and fluffy interior. They felt comforting and elegant, with a gentle buttery taste that encouraged savoring each bite.

The cream spread smoothly, and the jam added a sweet, fruity touch, creating a balanced and complete experience. Rating: 8.5/10: Delicious and delightful, but not extraordinarily flavorful.

Sandwiches:

The sandwiches were charming and special. The soft bread and flavorful fillings were well-prepared, making each bite delightful and satisfying.

Some sandwiches were creamy and smooth, others savory and fresh, all without overpowering flavors. Rating: 9.8/10: Absolutely delicious.

Desserts:

The desserts at Palm Court were visually stunning, with exquisite details. They were fresh and well-baked, with some being perfectly light and others overly sweet. The best ones were balanced and delightful. Rating: 9/10: Some hits and misses, but overall delicious.

Service: The service was exceptional, with attentive and detailed staff, and the food arrived promptly. Rating: 9.5/10

In conclusion, both afternoon teas at the Palm Court and Blue Box Cafe Tiffany’s were delightful, but I found the Palm Court slightly superior due to fresher food and quicker service. Thank you for reading my review. I hope you try both Afternoon Tea at Palm Court at the Plaza Hotel and Afternoon Tea at Tiffany’s Blue Box Cafe!